Reply
  Bookmark and Share #1  
Old 11-15-2012, 07:45 PM
drudo drudo is offline
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 8
Default Shotokan Karate Magazine - "Older Practition" by Bolin Smith

Post your comments, feedback, viewpoints and insights regarding the Shotokan Karate Magazine article Sensei John instructed us to read here.

-D
Reply With Quote
  Bookmark and Share #2  
Old 11-25-2012, 10:12 PM
drudo drudo is offline
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 8
Default

Flat out I think this was a poor article because it rambles and because I disagree with his view point.

Mr. Smith clearly undervalues the importance and genius of kata and while his viewpoint may have softened and expanded over the years, he still isn't crazy about kata.

From another SKM article I read about South African karate, the experience is a bit difference, so when Mr. Smith talks about Jet Fueled kumite we're talking knock-outs and blood and breaks, a very different experience from the USA/BSKA experience where we hope to avoid injury to ourselves and our sparring partners.

He makes some interesting comments about trying kata different ways, i.e. on the right side, in reverse, adding an extra kick or punch in between each technique. This won't be new to you if you train with Sensei John.

-Dru
Reply With Quote
  Bookmark and Share #3  
Old 11-26-2012, 01:48 PM
fglino fglino is offline
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 1
Default

I have difficulty visualizing what a 180 degree reverse gidan barai would look like after each oi zuki? Can anybody draw this diagram?
Mr. Z always say "slower is better for kata training!"
Reply With Quote
  Bookmark and Share #4  
Old 12-04-2012, 02:42 AM
drudo drudo is offline
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 8
Default

I think it would basically be technique 3 from Heian Shodan. I.e. Technique 2 is the oi tzuki, technique 3 you turn clockwise 180 degrees and execute gaidan borai.

I wasn't sure if he meant by "reverse" gaidon borai an ude borai or if he just meant "turn around, gaidan borai".

Either way, though, its not a bad idea to try kata different way or try to transition from every technique into every other techniqe and find new combinations of transitioning from one to the other.

Last edited by drudo; 12-04-2012 at 02:44 AM.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Share this thread on:
Thread Tools
Display Modes


Travelers411 Featured Content
Travelers411 Mini Sites
Featured Content

Visit the Travelers411 Directory for
National Trust for Historic Preservation

Click here to visit the Travelers411 Directory for National Trust for Historic Preservation

Working to save America’s historic places.

Travelers411 - Travel PR Sidebar Widget

Travel PR from
US Department of State, Department of Consular Affairs

US Department of State, Department of Consular Affairs

Travel PR From: US Department of State, Department of Consular Affairs. Click here to listen now.

Your US Passport is your key to travel abroad. Overview of passport office services and expedited services.

Travelers411 Mini Sites

Travel Deal for
Taste of Troy Food Tours LLC

Spring has erupted in Upstate NY. Looking for the perfect activity to share with your mom or dad in 2019? Book a Taste of Troy Food Tour, 3 hour progressive meals with a side of history - Fridays in Albany or Saturdays in Troy. Save 50% off their ticket...

Click here for details



Travelers411.com Navigation
Click here to visit the Travelers411 Directory for Columbia County Tourism Department and Film Office

Discover Columbia County in New York State's Hudson Valley Region. Situated about 2 hours north of New York City with Amtrak service to the town of Hudson. The county is known for its rich farming tradition with several local restaurants ...

The Travelers411 Family of Brands:   Travelers411.com     sAbrams.com     Travelingfeet.com     Jetset411.com

© 2019 Travelers411. All Rights Reserved. Travelers411 is a Registered Trademark. "Your Travel Community" TM. "Explore Your World" TM. Travelers411, all subpages and sub domains are protected by US Copyright law. We strive to respect the Copyrights of others. Please do not post material to this site for which you do not have proper permission from the copyright holder. To request use or report abuse please contact us.